نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی
عنوان مقاله English
نویسندگان English
This study investigates the relationship between the state and the visual arts market in
post-Islamic Revolution Iran through the lens of the configuration approach. The configuration approach, grounded in the relational theory of the state and the economy(market), frames these two entities as interconnected and interactive. The research method consists of two main stages: the first stage involved document analysis, and the second employed semi-structured interviews. For analyzing the data gathered from both documents and interviews, thematic analysis was used.In the first part, in order to understand how the state and market interact, 30 documents related to the visual arts were collected, coded, and analyzed using thematic analysis.Subsequently, to deepen the identified themes and gain insights into the state of the visual arts from the perspective of key actors, semi-structured interviews were conducted with gallery owners, artists, and officials.The final themes extracted from the documents included: “growth and development,” “laws and regulations,” “support,” “buying and selling,” and “cooperation and communication.” While these themes seemed to align with the state’s general objectives in the visual arts, the documents—being authored by high-level authorities in the form of regulations, strategic plans, and statutes—reflected a formal and bureaucratic tone, stemming from a top-down, holistic management approach that
neglected the specific details and capacities of different sectors.
Finally, this study revealed that the current configuration between the state and the visual arts market in Iran is inefficient, fragmented, and lacks effective and sustainable collaboration. The government has neither succeeded in playing the role of an effective supporter and policymaker nor in designing mechanisms for genuine participation by the artistic community. However, the government could have shifted from an interventionist to a facilitative role by strengthening intermediary institutions, reducing direct control, and establishing infrastructures to promote the social responsibility of professional organizations (CSR), independent artists’ associations, gallery owners, and art critics. These institutions could function both as intermediaries between the government and actors in this field and as mechanisms for regulating market relations.
Nonetheless, a comparison between official documents and field data from interviews indicates a significant gap between policy and the practical realities of this domain— a gap that has hindered the effective functioning of all three sectors (the state, the market, and the artistic community), placing the existing capacities of Iran’s visual arts scene in a state of uncertainty. The findings showed that the government’s presence in the visual arts has not been characterized by targeted and developmental support, but rather has taken a bureaucratic, and at times ideological, approach. This has ultimately resulted in “ineffective and restrictive state intervention.” Such intervention has not only failed to enhance the efficiency of the art market but has also, in many cases, led to legal ambiguities, arbitrary decisions, and unfair distribution of resources—factors that have fostered a “disconnect” instead of an interactive relationship between the government, the market, and the artistic community.
Ultimately, this research, by focusing on the relationship between the state and the market in the visual arts field within the conceptual framework of the configuration approach, showed that the formation of an interactive, stable, and constructive model among these entities still faces numerous structural and institutional barriers and gaps. Although official documents and national cultural policies emphasize the supportive and guiding role of the government in promoting the visual arts, field data from this study suggest that these goals face serious practical challenges. The reciprocal and interactive relationship envisioned by the configuration approach has not yet materialized between the state, the art market, and the visual arts community in Iran.
Rather than being based on cooperation and synergy, the interaction among these sectors has been shaped by inefficient interventions, communication breakdowns, and the absence of effective intermediary institutions, leading to a climate of mistrust, fragmentation, and passivity. This disconnect stems from inefficient bureaucracy, inflexible regulations, and policymaking that often excludes active participation from artists. As a result, a superficial and showcase-oriented relationship has emerged between artists and state institutions—used more for gaining legitimacy or short-term resources than for fostering sustainable cultural engagement (e.g., obtaining permits at the outset of gallery operations).
In such a context, although the visual arts market has experienced significant growth (according to statistics), it has largely developed independently and apart from the formal and supervisory structures of the state. Depending on their position, art actors have either become passive or have engaged with the state from a self-interested, utilitarian standpoint. Therefore, contrary to the fundamental premise of the configuration approach, which emphasizes interaction between the state and the market, what can be observed in Iran’s visual arts is a “fragmented and disconnected configuratiointeraction between the state and the market)what is observed in Iran’s visual arts is a “fragmented and disconnected configuration” between the state and the visual arts, with artists pursuing growth and survival through informal and networked processes among themselves.
کلیدواژهها English