Rahpooye Honar-Ha-Ye Tajassomi

Rahpooye Honar-Ha-Ye Tajassomi

A comparative study of the role of man-fish in the illustrations of the story of Jonah in the Quran and the first manifestation of Vishnu in the Hindu religion

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 PhD in Analytical and Comparative History of Islamic Art, . Faculty of Arts, Shahed University, Tehran, Iran.
2 Associate Professor, Islamic Art department. Faculty of Arts, Shahed University.
3 Associate Professor, Islamic Art department. Faculty of Arts, Shahed University, Tehran, Iran.
Abstract
Many symbolic images and motifs are present in the myths of different nations. These symbolic motifs later entered the religious arts. Many painters have depicted these stories and their examinations could help represent the concepts and inner meanings of religion. This paper considers the story of Yunus in the Quran and Indian story of the first appearance of Vishnu, the protector, in Hindu religions. In this study, first, the history of the man-fish myth was studied and after that a short story of Prophet Yunus was given in the Quran along with the first emanation of Vishnu. Based on symbolic elements, the works of Islamic and Indian paintings related to these texts will be examined. The motif of "man-fish" in Mesopotamia mythology and other cultures of the world are existent from thousands of years ago. In Assyrian and Babylonian mythology, there was a God whose upper body was a man and lower body was like a fish. The followers of Enki, God of fresh waters in the Sumerian civilization, who later became Ea in the Babylonian civilization, are depicted in this way. Kolulu" is also the name the Assyrians chose for this half-human half-fish creature, and this creature was one of Enki's supporters. Many of these stories have been existed orally or written, and if they were lost in a civilization, they were found again in the story of Yunus. We can observe that the painters have depicted the story of Yunus, which was associated with fish and water in relation to mythological images of man-fish in the Islamic illustrations of the stories in the Quran. The mentioned items are very similar to the pictures of Yunus and Vishnu, which have been investigated many times. Examples of this coalescence can be seen in the pictures obtained as illustrated versions in various religions of the world, including Islam and Hinduism. This research identifies and introduces the symbols and signs used in these works to interpret and achieve multiple layers of their meanings. To achieve this aim, the author tried answering these questions: 1. what are the similarities and differences between the pictures of Yunus and Vishnu? 2. What is the reason for using the image of man-fish in Islamic and Indian civilizations? The method in this study is descriptive-analytical with a comparative and analytically quantitative approach. This paper studies comparatively Islamic and Indian paintings related to the story of Yunus in the Quran and the first emanation of Vishnu in the Hindu religion ( from 14th to 18th AD., from 8th  to 12th AH.). These involve five pictures of Islamic art and five pictures of Indian art. To access the research references, library, electronic and image view have been used. To achieve the assumed result, it will be tried matching the structure of Islamic and Indian images according to the aim of this study. The results obtained from the comparison of the images will lead to the discovery of hidden layers of meaning to using a common image in two civilizations and cultures. Investigations have shown that the images of Yunus and Vishnu along with fish show the effects of mythological motifs of man-fish, but different meanings of this image are received in Islamic and Indian civilizations. Examples of this coalescence can be seen in the pictures obtained in the form of illustrated versions in various religions of the world, including Islam and Hinduism. Both the pictures related to the story of Prophet Yunus in the Quran and pictures of the story of the first avatar Vishnu, Hindu deities (Brahma, Vishnu, and Shiva) controversially contain an image of man-fish. This research examined this image comparatively. Vishnu is a heavenly God in the Hindu religion and, as we know, gods must emanate as something else. So the emanation of Vishnu seems completely reasonable in the form of man-fish or better to say that God-fish, which has a direct influence of mythological religions because Vishnu is a God. In mythological religions, gods are worshiped as the hybrid creatures. Also, in the Hindu scriptures, the image of Vishnu and his emanation are mentioned directly, but the image of man-fish in Islamic paintings shows a man who is God's prophet combined with a fish. This is unprecedented. This is because there are no references and definitions for these hybrid creatures and special signs for Yunus in the Quran. So, the painter has combined the image of Yunus the prophet with a fish based on the mythological image in non-Arab religions to give God-like and holy awe to him.  
- A reason to use the image of fish in coalescence with Yunus and Vishnu is the reference to the Hindu scriptures and the Quran and their connection with fish.
Keywords

The Holy Quran.
Ahmadi, Babak (2009), From Tomton's Visual Signs. Eighth edition, Tehran, Markaz Publishing.
Afshari, Morteza; Ayatollahi, Habibollah and Rajabi, Mohammad Ali (2009), A Study of the Symbolism of Icons in Islamic Painting from a Semiotic Perspective. Bi-Quarterly Scientific-Research Journal of Islamic Art Studies, No. 13, Autumn and Winter, pp. 54-37, Afshari Faraki, Morteza, Ayatollahi, Habibollah, and Rajabi, Mohammad Ali. (2009). A Study of the Symbolism of Icons in Islamic Painting from a Semiotic Perspective. Islamic Art Studies, 7(13), 37-54. Doi:
https://sid.ir/paper/136849/fa
Elyadeh, Mircha, (1995), Myth, Dream, Mystery. Translated by Roya Monjem, Tehran, Fekr Rooz Publications.
Black, Jeremy and Green, Anthony (2006), Dictionary of Gods, Divans and Symbols of Ancient Mesopotamia. Translated by Peyman Matin, Tehran, Amir Kabir.
Pakzad, Zahra (2011), The Role of Divans and Demonic Beings in the Illustrations of the Shahnameh Rashida, Quarterly Journal of Mystical and Mythological Literature. Year 7, Issue 22, Spring.
Paydarfard, Arezo; Mohammadzadeh, Mehdi and Balkhari-Ghahi, Hassan. (2018), Analysis of the Quranic Counterdiscourse of the Two Illustrations of Prophet Joseph in Prison and Prophet Yunus and the Fish from the Falnameh of Shah Tahmasbi. Bagh-e-Nazar, 15(69), 29-38Doi: . https://sid.ir/paper/514719/fa
Prada, Edith (2004), Ancient Iranian Art. Translated by Yousef Majidzadeh, Tehran, Tehran University Press.
Jobs, Gertrude (2001), Symbols. Mohammad Reza Baghapour, Translator's Publication, Tehran.
Jalali Naeini, Mohammad Reza (1988), Selections from Rig Veda (Research and Translation). Second Edition, Tehran, Noghreh.
Javaheri, Faezeh and Mohammadzadeh, Mehdi (2017), Iconography of the Figure of Adam (PBUH) in the Images of the Prostration of Angels, Jelweh Honar, Year 9, Issue 2 (18th Consecutive), Autumn and Winter, pp. 106-97. Doi: 10.22051/jjh.2017.7610.1034.
Zekrgo, Amir Hossein (1998), Secrets of Indian Mythology (Vedic Gods). Fekr Rooz Publications.
Shaygan, Dariush (2009), Religions and Philosophical Schools of India. Vol. 1, Seventh Edition, Tehran, Amir Kabir Publications.
Chevalier, Jean and Alain Gerberan (2009), Culture of Symbols. Translated by Sudabeh Fazaeli, 5 vols., 3rd ch., Tehran, Jeyhoun.
Sahi, Manijeh (2005), Nature of Water, Wind, Soil and Fire in the Articles of the First Symposium on Art and the Elements of Nature (Water-Soil-Air and Fire), Academy of Arts.
Qojehzadeh, Alireza; Nikoei, Mozhgan; Khodadadi Mahabadi, Masoumeh and Kakavand Qalehnoui, Fatemeh (2010), Conceptual Adaptation of the Fish Symbol in Mythology, the Quran and the Spiritual Masnavi and Its Application in Works of Art. Scientific-Research Journal of Islamic Art Studies, Year 16, Issue 36, Winter, pp. 278-259. .Doi:org/10.22034/ias.2020.104408
Kamrani, Behnam (2006), Genealogy of Angels in Iranian Painting. Book of the Month of Art, August and September, pp. 52-64.
Lings, Martin (1995), The Symbol of Water in the Quran. Translated by Seyyed Rahim Musavinia, Quarterly Journal of Art, 28, pp. 52-64. http://noo.rs/rnBsX.
Mokhtarian, Bahar and Sarami, Arefeh (1984), Structural Analysis of the Duality of the Symbol of the Two Fishes, Iranian Anthropological Research, Volume 4, Issue 20, Fall and Winter. Doi:org/10.22059/ijar.2014.55496 .
Mokhtarian, Bahar (1991), The Importance of Iconography and Iconology in Religious Studies; The Iconology of Jonah and the Fish, Art Review, Year 1, Issue 1, Winter.
Mesbah, Bita, Hojabari Nobari, Alireza, Tavousi, Mahmoud, and Esmaeil Pour, Abolghasem. (1993). Analytical-mythological study of the images of the three goddesses of fish, plants and water in Iran (1500-3200 BC). Letter of Visual and Applied Arts, 6(12), 77-92. SID. https://sid.ir/paper/481072/fa.
Namwar Motlagh, Bahman (2015), Illustrated Dictionary of Iranian Symbols, Tehran, Shahr Publishing House.
Hall, James, (2004), Dictionary of Symbols in the Art of the East and the West, translated by Roghieh Behzadi, Tehran: Contemporary Culture.
Volume 7, Issue 3
Autumn 2024
Pages 25-35

  • Receive Date 25 March 2023
  • Revise Date 23 March 0621
  • Accept Date 15 August 2024