Peer Review Process

Peer Review Policy

Journal of Rahpooye Honar-Ha-Ye Tajassomi uses a double anonymous peer review policy for article reviews and refereeing. This means that the identity of the author and reviewers will be anonymous in the process. Therefore, the authors should note that their article should not disclose the authors' information in any way.


Article review time

Article review time varies depending on the topic and quality of the article (an article may need several stages of review and correction). In addition, each referee at each stage has 30 days of refereeing time.


Peer Review Process

The procedures for reviewing, accepting, and publishing articles in the Rahpooye Honar-Ha-Ye Tajassomi are as follows:

1- Preliminary review and announcement of the editor-in-chief's opinion

In the first stage, the editor examines the article to ensure compliance with the publication's format and the similarity and appropriateness of the journal's scope.
The article will penetrate the next stage if the editor's opinion is optimistic about the mentioned items.
If the article needs to be edited regarding the above, it will be returned to the authors.
The article will be rejected if the editor's opinion is pessimistic about the abovementioned items.
 

2- Review and Revision

If the files are completed and the publication format is fully respected, the article will be sent to three referees simultaneously.
Receiving the results of the arbitration and sending to the author to make corrections;
receiving corrections and submitting the article for final judging;
If the files are complete and the things mentioned in the editing letter are followed, the article will be sent to the previous referees to control the final corrections.
If the referee results are negative, the article will be rejected.
 

3- Comparative review and final assessment

Receiving the opinions of the final referee and presenting the article in the editorial meeting to announce the final opinion;
If the final referee approves the author's corrections, the article will be presented in the editorial meeting to determine the assignment.
Placement of accepted articles in the list of articles ready for publication
 

4- Preparing and publishing the article

All articles are sent to the responsible author after page layout and editing before publishing. If anything needs to be controlled and changed, the author's approval for publication is obtained.

All correspondence is done with the corresponding author.


 

 

Peer Review Process